This week’s Crumbl Cookies lineup is Caramel Pumpkin, Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Cream, Raspberry Butter Cake and Lemon Glaze. These were a total impulse buy this week. I had zero clue on the flavors and no intention of buying any this week. The next thing I knew, I had a 4-pack in my hands! Lol 🤪 Here’s the 411!
+ Caramel Pumpkin - This one was a pumpkin cookie with a caramel cream-cheese frosting. Keeping it real— I could take it or leave it. I didn’t find anything out of the ordinary about it but I also didn’t dislike. It had a subtle hint of spice which wasn’t too overpowering but the caramel flavor never really came through for me.
+ Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Cream - Winner winner, PB dinner! This one was SO delicious. I’m always a sucker for their peanut butter flavors so if you also like peanut butter, you’ll love. The creamy frosting was delicious with the crunchy Nutter Butter pieces mixed in. I also liked that the cookie was chilled + had a little crunch.
+ Raspberry Butter Cake - My second fave of the week! I love raspberry which was up front and center in this cookie. It’s very much an in your face raspberry with a zing! I loved that— very sweet mixed with the buttercream. The cookie itself was so-so. I haven’t loved the classic butter cake cookie but the topping masked most of it’s flavor. I think it’s always a little too gummy and underbaked for my liking. Besides that, I enjoyed the rest of it!
+ Lemon Glaze - Yummy if you like lemon. I’ve never been a huge fan of lemon desserts, but I always really enjoy Crumbl’s. This one was very comparable to all of the others I’ve tried so pretty much what I expected. I like the sweet, zingy flavor. Not too tart but refreshing.
What flavor would you pick?
